Friday, April 04, 2008

Providing opportunities to develop students passions and interests.













A creative teacher is always on the alert for an opportunity to involve students in meaningful learning - in this case learning about why archaeologists need to research an early Maori settlement. The students found the experience fascinating.

I have always liked the quote from Jerome Bruner that , 'teaching is the canny art of intellectual temptation.' Students are innately curious and if they have developed a range of interests they will do almost anything to learn more about, or get better, at it.

The New Zealand Curriculum asks teachers to see their students as active 'seekers, users, and creators of their own knowledge'. Achieving this will provide a real challenge to many school

Our identity is closely linked to what we are good at doing, or the interests a we have, and so it makes sense to expose students to a range of experiences that provide opportunities to develop, uncover, or amplify, their interests.

A recent Ministry of Education publication, 'Assessing Key Competencies' suggests that we need a new metaphor for assessment - 'performance'. I can't resist a comment that this idea is hardly new - except to those who have been distracted from such a common sense idea by traditional educational assessing for accountability or, a little better, for acquiring teacher defined skills or content.

Performance , to me , suggests performances of student's talents rather than 'key competencies' but I agree key competencies are integral to any performance.

I just have a feeling that developing talents and interests have not been fully appreciated by current thinking - the emphasis is that the 'key competencies are at the heart of the curriculum.' This emphasis requires new forms of assessment beyond the 'old basics'.

I agree with the document that students need to develop an identity as a learner who is, 'ready willing and able' to apply themselves to any new learning challenge. I have aways liked the business firm that uses, 'Know how , can do', as it vision phrase but would add to to it , 'don't know how but will give it a go.'

A performance is seen as a complex mix of competencies and needs to judged as a whole after the performance as part of an ongoing creative process. This is not to say that specific elements cannot be highlighted for future improvement.

Teachers are asked, in the document to 'audit' the opportunities they provides to develop key competencies ( and I would add students talents and interests)?

What 'rich tasks' ( a term for topics designed as part of the Queensland 'New Basics') are being provided that allow the development of 'new literacies' to add to the old basics of reading writing and literacy'?

Other phrases sum up the 'spirit' of such learning: Inquiry Learning, Project, or problem , Based learning; generative topics and 'ill defined problems'. They all involve both teacher and students moving into new area of learning making use, in the process, all the key competencies and the various disciplines.

Some examples I have observed:

In depth ecological studies of natural environments - a piece of bush ( The missing cloak of Tane), long grass, a lawn, the seashore, streams one class studies a river from source to sea), life in the soil and studies of single plants ( the flax) and animals ( cicadas/wasps). One school studied the human body and skeleton extending into health and well being.

Exploring physical science topics from the science of fight (making kites) to household chemistry ( cooking).

Studies of other cultures, past and present, to develop cultural literacy. Studying recently migrated cultures using class new mates.

Exploring heritage building in the local environment ). One class studied styles of architecture). One excellent study was based on exploring the symbolism of a church. Oral history of those involved in WW2 ( linked in with ANZAC Day) another remembrances of older people in the community.

Art themes such as printing ( and writing) through the ages from clay tiles to multi media printing. The art and science of firing clay. Making videos and multi media presentations. Photography from pin hole to digital cameras.

Intensive studies of Maori, or Pasifica, culture - researching a pa site; exploring Maori, or Pacifica, art and craft. History of life and times of famous early Maori fighting chiefs. Life and times of a pakeha Maori:Kimble Bent.

Exploring maths topics such as patterns ( involving a range of Learning Areas) measuring, geometry in the environment.

Many of the above were planned by the teacher ( or teams of teachers) but a number arose through taking advantage of 'teachable moments'. However they were introduced activities and 'performances' were negotiated with students.

The best assessment , or demonstration, of key competencies would be for a student( or group of students) to undertake a self chosen independent study. Not only would this demonstrate what students know but would also indicate areas teachers need to focus on. At the beginning of each year is another time to assess what competencies ( and talents) students bring with them.

For a creative teacher the years programme could 'emerge' from students interests, concerns and teachable moments but, even for such a teacher, it is easy enough to ensure that the strands of the learning Areas are covered. It is vital that, whatever is studied, is done well to ensure 'deep' learning.

The key competencies maybe the 'heart of the curriculum' but the development of every students talents and interests are central to of each individual learning identity. I guess it depends on your point of view!

Take a look around your class, or school, what opportunities are being offered to develop either?

Wednesday, April 02, 2008

We could be the Finland of the South?

One region of the world scores high in international science and maths tests - and also tops reading, is Scandinavia. New Zealand does reasonably well - coming in around seventh or so. Why is this?

Americans are always researching, or visiting, to find out why other countries do well in International testing ( since their industrial aged model system is predicated on standardized testing).They are aways surprised to find other countries that do far better than them. Conformist Asian countries are one such group that score well but Scandinavia is more interesting. Forgetting that the testing may well be looking for the wrong attributes for the 21stC, it is worth looking to see what they do in Scandinavia.

But first a few thoughts about the New Zealand scene. Once we were world leaders in reading ( we still do well) but with the imposition of the, now seen as failing standardized, curriculum of the 90s, we seem to have lost our edge.

It is not that we don't know what to do to remedy the situation. The Ministry 'preisthood' is full of self congratulation for it's Best Evidence Synthesis, proudly stating that an oversea educationalist ( from Canada) says it is , 'the smartest intellectual property in the world. Reading it will show that most of it states what creative educators, past and present, have aways known. The Ministry, after recently discovering it is the quality of the individual teacher that is the key to real student achievement, has now discovered the , 'evidence is emerging...that show the role of the principal is central to creating the right conditions for effective learning and teaching.' Both amazingly obvious one would have thought?

Such Ministry success is paraded in their recent Newsletter but the real 'evidence' lies in the reality of our schools. Figures still indicate large achievement gaps with up to 25% of all students, still leaving with little to show for their time. Secondary schools, in particular, seem impervious to the 'best evidence research' and remain locked in their academic straightjacket's.

So what is they do in Finland. A country, by the way that has lowered dramatically its diabetic and prison population rates, problems that we have yet to face up to in New Zealand

An American delegation, visiting to see how the Scandinavians were able to score so highly in recent international tests, found that educators in Finland, Sweden and Denmark all cited, 'autonomy and project based learning', as keys to their success. What they didn't find was competitive comparisons of schools, complicated curriculum, standardized testings and top-down accountability - all staples of the American system.

Credit to Finland's success were attributed to major reforms of the 1970s that placed an emphasis on primary education. All three countries start formal education at age seven after participating in extensive early childhood and pre-school programmes focused on self reflection and social behaviour, rather than academic content. By focusing on self reflection, students learn to become responsible for their own education. Philosophical thought is encouraged at an early age and student grading doesn't happen until the high school level because they believe it takes the fun out of learning. They want to inspire continuous learning.

Self reflection, philosophical thinking, fun and inspiration - great words!

Educators, in Scandinavian countries, view accountability far differently than in the United States. In contrast to the quantitative measures and standardized testing found in their 'No Child Left Behind' Scandinavians rely on a system that produces highly competent teachers who use their professional expertise to work with each student to develop individualized learning plans. In Finland such plans are completed when students achieve tertiary education or their first job.

My teacher' and 'the teacher' are terms of respect, not only when used by the student but also school principals. The teacher is viewed as a mentor, someone with the knowledge and wisdom to impart and who plays a key role in preparing students for adulthood. Teaching is a highly respected and sought after career. It is interesting to note that respect for teachers is also mark of Asian countries.

Scandinavians countries have established national curriculum standards but have set broad mandates, letting authority trickle down as close to the classroom as possible. Communities have the flexibility to provide services according to their students unique needs and interests as long as the basic policy statement is followed.

This is the essence of the 'new' New Zealand Curriculum but we are just starting the journey having been diverted by, the now enlightened, Ministry the past decades.

In Scandinavian countries teachers are extremely autonomous in their work , so are students. While in the US 'teachers are held accountable for teaching, here they hold students accountable for their own learning'. Students become independent learners working across curricular areas and it is common for one teacher, or mentor, to stay with students from grade one to nine, with students moving freely about the building. School libraries are seen as pedagogical centres.

In Denmark students are judged in relation to their own growth, rather than that of others, and they are continually evaluated. Teachers also write individual learning plans for each student after these evaluations. American visitors found this remarkable!

Project based learning begins in the first grade and teachers work with students to structure their learning through a process described as 'dialogue and trust'. Assessment is achieved primarily through a dialogue with each student, as is communication with parents about their child's progress. Exams tend to be limited as exit criteria to grade nine, along with project based assignments that require students to plan, research, present and create around a broad theme.

Along similar lines our 'new' New Zealand Curriculum asks teachers to see students as, 'seekers, users and creators of their own knowledge', something creative teachers have always done.

Changes in Scandinavian occurred because teachers felt the system stifled them and hindered creativity in the classroom. One Finish school believes students should, 'have fun and know the joy of life.

Best Evidence Synthesis is one thing - changing the system to create every student as a life long learners is another.

More about Finland

And even more
.

Tuesday, April 01, 2008

Challenges of learning in the 21stC

Jackson Pollock painted images in the 1950s that may have predicted the ambiguity, challenges and excitement that future decades hold?


Our 'new' New Zealand Curriculum asks teacher to 'see' their students as active seekers, users and creators of their own knowledge. Students who can see 'connections' are able to call on, or integrate, various disciplines to solve problems.

It is no longer appropriate to see knowledge as prepackaged into subject boxes to be transmitted to students - who by nature are now no longer willing to accept second hand learning from their teachers.

Those who try to impose learning on students are fighting a battle that will be lost in the decades to come. In the meantime the 'knowledge priesthood' that reside in the Ministry, and secondary school subject departments, continue to try to retain their primacy. Add to this the reactionary 'default position' of primary teachers who cant see past the Victorian literacy and numeracy dogma.

Anybody who wants knowledge can access 'wikipedia' or search via 'google'. What is important for learners is to keep their curiosity intact; to continue to be exited about learning; to sort out which knowledge is authentic; and to develop their creativity and imagination.

What we need to teach is to help students trust themselves to learn how to become aware of and solve their own problems. Our teaching must result in students actually enjoying solving problem by creating their own artifacts of knowledge, or personal expressions, using whatever media they choose to select.

The role of future teachers in achieving the above is both an exciting and challenging one; teaching inquiry and thinking approaches; how to interrogate information; providing information and media assistance; ensuring necessary skills are in place ( including literacy and numeracy); assisting students in their 'personalised' learning pathways; interacting in the role of a learning 'adviser' or 'coach'; and, most of all, creating safe and stimulating learning environments.

To achieve this will require the dissolution of subject boxes and for teachers and students to work in teams. Balancing team work while still encouraging singular acts of creativity will make teaching far more exciting - but not for teachers ( and students) who have grown used to their boxes.

All learning 'emerges' from what someone called 'cognitive inconsistency' - when things don't seem to work out as expected. All learning is a creative act of personal construction - meaning cannot simply be passed on to students without something being lost in the process. All learners have to face up to jettisoning old knowledge to allow new idea to seep into the subconscious. Education is literally about changing ones mind.

Control of knowledge has to be wrested away from the 'knowledge priesthood' who presume to know better. New minds need to able to see connections between disparate areas of learning while at the same time calling on knowledge from the various disciplines.

And learning is more than pure logic. Intuition, feelings and imagination are to be valued if new ideas are to evolve.

Students as creators of their own knowledge requires 'new minds', or minds before they were hardened into categories by faulty schooling.

Students as creators requires new schools.

Students, who will thrive in the future, will need to be driven by their curiosity, able to call on past learning as required.

Such schools are hard to find today but they do exist in the minds of many creative teachers.

Leaders, who can combine such teacher creativity with the innate curiosity of students, will have begun the development of future schools.

Monday, March 31, 2008

Teaching with passion

















It is all about, 'building relationships, fostering creativity and standing up for students' Johnathon Kozol


Passionate teachers do not care about curriculums or school 'targets', they only care about developing each students growing sense of self identity and worth.

Passionate teaching, according to Johnathon Kozol is about, 'establishing a chemistry between the children and ourselves'. This 'chemistry' is far more important than whatever knowledge teachers think worth imparting. 'Entrap them first in fascination,' he continues,'entrap them in a sense of merriment and hopeful expectation.'

Johnathon Kozol has been writing about creative education since the 1960s. He is a sharp critic of the 'status quo' and a longtime critic of the accountability driven culture that currently pervades and distorts western education systems. He also dismisses the 'reliance on so called 'experts' dispensing professional development, and 'scripted curricula, from the outside.'

It is not as bad in our own country but all is not well.

The 'new' New Zealand Curriculum now provides an opportunity for teachers to become central players in developing a creative education system if only they weren't so exhausted from complying to the endless debilitating demands imposed on them the past decades. Today teachers are under so much pressure to perform to outside expectations to find the time to really focus on the creative needs of their students.

Kozol's advice is, that if you are going to inject some, 'healthy irreverent merriment... you have to deliver the goods some way...you have to have high expectations of them'.

Going against the grain is not easy , requiring great courage, but creative teachers can win immunity by helping their students achieve well beyond any ones expectation, including the students.

Creative education and personalised learning go hand in hand and Kozol suggests that teachers need , 'a big dose of mischievous irrelevance if (they) want to survive with their soul intact'.

Teachers, he writes, need to pay attention to both the joy and rigour involved in high achievement and, to appreciate this, they need to observe enlightened creative teachers in action. Only such first hand observation will expose them to the possibilities of a better way to teach.

Creative teaching is 'tough love' teaching, and is well summed up in a quote by Dan Rather a US broadcaster, 'The dream begins with a teacher who believes in you, who tugs and pushes you to the next plateau, sometimes poking you with a sharp stick called the truth'.

Too soft teachers are often reluctant to challenge the learners for fear of pushing too hard. The truly creative teacher establishes rapport and senses unspoken needs, all the time respecting learners autonomy. The true teacher acts as a catalyst, asks probing questions, observes and listens ,allowing students time for to gather their thoughts, and, in the process, making students aware of possible choices they need to make.

Students learn to trust teacher who give them appropriate stress, pain, or practice, when needed, and resent those teachers who push them for their own ends, or don't push them enough.

'Too soft a teachers' reinforce the learners natural wish to retreat and stay safe. Teachers need to learn when to, leave students to struggle and when to assist. Risk-taking, and trusting one intuition, brings its own rewards. These are attributes students will need in the 21stC.

Teaching, in this respect, is more an art than a science.

As the poet Apollinaire put it,

'Come to the edge, he said.
They said: We are afraid,
Come to the edge, he said,
They came.
He pushed them...and they flew.'

Those who love us well push us when we are ready to fly.

Thursday, March 27, 2008

Exploring the real world

Students who have been 'taught' to observe, draw and reflect are able to produce work of personal excellence.(Year six)

'Those who contemplate the beauty of the earth find reserves of strength that will endure as long as life lasts.' Rachel Carson author of 'The Silent Spring' a book that sparked the need for environmental protection.

If we wish to develop citizens who have an understanding of the need for sustainability then we ought to see as basic the need to help students respond to and interpret the world around them.

That this exploration leads into environmental studies, creative writing, language and artistic development is an added bonus but to take full advantage of such experiences students need to be 'taught' appropriate skills and attitudes.

Drawing is one such basic skill but unfortunately after about the age of 7 or 8 many children have developed the belief that they can't draw. Before this age children will cheerfully draw anything asked of them.

To overcome this 'can't do' attitude teachers need to give structured support to refuel children's curiosity by encouraging slower observation ( 'look- draw- look -draw'). If a stuffed pheasant, such things as, feather patterns, beak and eyes, legs and then, with the chosen medium, experimenting how to represent them.

Such intense observational drawing ( with associated growing skill in the chosen medium) ought not to result in a perfect realisation. Every student needs to capture their own personal interpretation of the pheasant - and each students piece of work needs to be valued and not judged by demeaning realist criteria.

In such an intense reflective process as drawing students will be thinking of many things and a sensitive teachers can, at a later time, develop such thoughts into study questions and poetic writing.

Ideally teachers might have introduced this bird study with a display to attract the students attention. Jerome Bruner wisely said that , 'intellectual temptation is the canny art of the teacher'. Such a display , spreading to the walls, will have added to it students questions, research, poetic language, and creative art work.

Exploring the visual environment ought not be left to chance particularly in this age of virtual reality. Through exploration of everyday things , all too often taken for granted, students will become aware of the language of visual exploration. Once this visual awareness is realised there is a wealth of natural and man made possibilities to explore in every school environment: buildings, bikes, plants, trees, gates, cars, kinds of sky and clouds, rain....

There is no need to go far and, armed with digital cameras, visual ideas can be bought back to the class for further explore and interpret.

Teachers need to keep a 'weather eye' for possibilities for students to explore and objects can be bought for home as well.

There are all sorts of ways to develop this environmental and visual awareness. Students can lie down, shut their eyes, stand on things to get a different view, and each of the senses can be explored separately.

Themes such as patterns, shapes, decoration, reflections, life cycles, can be explored, along with such things as, life in long grass, patches of bush, parks, car parks, stones, shells, fossils, historical artifacts, historical buildings, marae, local small businesses ( bike shops), backs of shops... each school can draw up their own list.

The key to it all is to focus the students on an area of interest, to provide experiences and resources to encourage first hand experiences in depth, and then , by working alongside the learner, to help students produce personal interpretations using whatever medium has been chosen.

Simple stuff but, when done well, amazing. It is about doing fewer things well.

And it all for free - the curriculum is to be found in within the students curiosity and the immediate environment. Best of all it takes advantage of the natural way students learn. Such an approach helps students make sense of their environment and their experiences.

Using such an approach the student is centre of his, or her, own learning
rather than imposed 'unrealistic' curriculums.

This approach does, however, depend on the enthusiasm of each teacher and the relationship between the 'teacher' ( 'co-explorer') and the learner.

It was the 'progressive approach' before overwhelmed by imposed Ministry curriculums - well up until now it seems.

Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Simple but Deep

Observation, a simple but absorbing experience leading into wondering and imagining; the basis of all learning.



The teachers I have worked the most with over the years believe strongly in the primacy of observation. A common conviction is the belief in first hand experience as the root of all learning.

There is a real need for direct experience of the real world as a starting point for as much class activity in science, social sciences,language and art, as is possible. It is all too easy in this age of instant ready made images to forget about the importance of real life observation.

Students need to be taught to observe more carefully to record faithfully what they see but, for this to happen, teachers themselves need to aware of the often overlooked beauty and small scale drama of the immediate world.

By educating students senses, encouraging them to notice shapes, textures, patterns , movements and colours, students develop an appreciation of and identity with their environment. They also develop, in the process, the language to express what they see and think. Before the word must come the experience - and if students are entering school with language deficiency it might well be this paucity of sensory experience that is the cause.

All too often this sensory appreciation loses its edge as children grow their attention being diverted to the divorced world of virtual pre- digested reality. One writer has said that, 'humanity has persistently been weaving a cocoon about itself...denying itself primary experience'.Technology: 'the knack of of so arranging the world that we don't have to experience it'.

Sensory deprivation, it has been shown, sets in when there is not enough sensory stimulation. Many children only experience their environment from the window of a fast moving car. Quietly observing the world by walking and wondering is almost a lost art.

With a sensitive teacher help students an be taught to slow down enough to notice the small easily overlooked immediate world. Such students will begin to take personal delight in experiencing such things as a: rain filled gutters, rain on windows, the first frost, monarch butterflies, mossy stones, shells, and dandelion seed heads. All these become available as the fundamental resources for further study back in class and will remain with children as special memories of childhood.

Such an approach was once common in classrooms.

The teachers I have worked with have placed the importance of observation central to their programmes. They deliberately teach the students to look carefully so so to really see what they are looking at. By deliberately 'slowing the pace' of student's work, not only does in-depth observational art result but, also, space is created for the teacher to come alongside the child to provide support and guidance. And, as students draw, thoughts and questions will arise which can be recorded to become the basis of quality research work, creative language, and imaginative art.

In such classrooms quality observational art, descriptive writing, and researched questions is seen along with poetic thoughts and highly imaginative creative art work.

Students educated in such rooms display an absorption and powers of observation that are truly scientific, sadly missing in too many classrooms today that have been pressurized by the rush to 'deliver' imposed curriculums.

Observation feeds curiosity, visual education and the imagination.

It is fundamental to all learning.

More schools should get back to such basics.

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

Still a need for Bruce's POV?



'If the 'new' New Zealand curriculum is so good maybe it's time to fade away?'

I happened to go to the funeral of a well respected liberal educator, in his late 80s, the other day. It was more celebration of his life as members of his family shared his beliefs, sang songs he enjoyed, showed some of his photography, and read one or two of his poems.

Afterwards I had the opportunity to read his autobiography and was particularity fascinated by the growth of his educational ideals that he outlined.

I learnt from my reading that after the depression of the 30s a New Education Fellowship Conference was held in New Zealand; the discussion that it invoked influenced educators of the time. This evolved into the ideas of Dr Beeby the Director of Education, appointed by the transformational first Labour Government. After World War Two progressive idea were in the air if not in the schools but, at least, there were innovative teachers beginning to develop more creative approaches to learning. Approaches that valued the individuality of each student and the importance of developing each learners unique creativity. Today we would call it personalisation.

Reading the autobiography it is clear that the ideals, now being expressed in the 'new' New Zealand Curriculum, are hardly new!

That the ideas spread so slowly is testament to the conservative nature of the education system.

The establishment of specialist advisers it seems was an important way to encourage teachers to develop new ideas - in particular the art advisers who were selected because of their potential to develop creativity. Being exposed to the value of creative art and language inspired the writer of the autobiography. Add to this the revolutionary ideas of the 60s and, by the 70s, innovative teachers were making their marks felt.

But traditional approaches were still the 'name of the game' well into the 70s, especially in bigger urban schools. Creativity though was emerging in small rural schools.

Taranaki became a well known in the 70s for creative education

This creativity was centred around a small group of teachers that I had the opportunity to work with as an science adviser. In the eighties I continued to work with a limited number of schools who developed a school wide approach to creative teaching.

It was during these times that Taranaki gained its well known reputation for creative education.

Then we had to suffer the imposition of curriculum based on strands, levels and countless learning objectives that put all the hard earned creativity at risk. It was all about standardisation, accountability and, eventually, a return to a 'Victorian' three Rs literacy and numeracy curriculum.

So now we have the 'new' New Zealand Curriculum; a curriculum that, although welcome, is hardly 'new' - more 'back to the future'.

It is as if the curriculum imposition of the 90s have been forgotten in this rush of Ministry 'revisionism'. The Ministry seems to be giving the liberal impression that it is all a natural progression, sidestepping responsibility for the confusion and teacher stress and burnout that their previous efforts created.

The phrases I do like is the idea that students should be their own, 'seekers, users and creators of knowledge' , and that there is a need to do 'fewer thing well'. These were ideas that I read in the autobiography I mentioned earlier.

You need a long memory to see that all is not new.

So is there still a need for the point of view I hold?

I am certain there is as school now 'clamber' to implement the 'new' curriculum without any understanding of what it means to be creative. Shallow creativity is all too easy to implement and is alive and well in our school where evidence of students 'clone like criteria based creativity' is all too evident.

What creative school needs to do, as always, is to:

1 Value the idiosyncratic gifts, talents, voice and identity of each individual student and to see this as a more important priority than literacy and numeracy - these ought to be seen as 'foundation skills,'

2 To develop 'emergent' curriculum based around students interests, concerns and immediate environment. Such an approach leads to a a naturally integrated approach. Class studies ( or 'rich topics') becomes the source of the intellectual energy for the class by tapping into the innate curiosity of all students.

3 To do 'fewer things well' and to value, not only the inquiry process, but also quality of the creative product, or depth of individual student thinking. The room environment should celebrate the questions, theories, and creative language and art, of the students. The 'new' New Zealand Curriculum values this as personal excellence - hardly a new value. Displaying student work is as much aesthetics as it is celebratory and informative - it is the third teacher and main 'message system' of the school.

Assisting students develop aesthetic design skills to present their work with individual flair and creativity is also important and ought to be seen in every page in all students book work.

4 The role of the teacher needs to be one of coming alongside the learner assisting students to do their own learning -another idea expressed in the autobiography I read. The teachers I admire gain their greatest satisfaction when their students surprise them ( and themselves) by the quality of their thinking and creativity.

5 If the above is the 'artistry' of teaching then developing classroom organisational patterns that 'allow' such work is the 'craft' of teaching. This requirement has been with teachers from the first days teachers attempted to 'personalise' their teaching and move away from standardized approaches such as lecturing, ability grouping or streaming.

When I see such elements ,which it seems have been a part of creative mindsets from the beginning, in all classrooms then, maybe, it is time to give it all away.

But, as I said, education is a conservative system.

Until then I will continue to add my 'point of view' to the continuing debate.

Thursday, March 20, 2008

Inspiration from the classroom.

We should look to our creative teachers, past and present, for inspiration - not distant experts.








There is not much that is 'new' in our 'new' New Zealand Curriculum but none the less it is a welcome shift from the Ministry's past technocratic thinking. A couple of phrases are particularly welcome by creative teachers. One , that students should be, 'active seekers, users and creators of ( their own) knowledge', and the suggestion to work with, 'fewer contexts in greater depth'.

To find the 'new' curriculum in action teachers need to seek out those creative teachers, who largely ignored previous 'official' advice, to see examples of teachers who are themselves 'seekers, users and creators of their own knowledge'.

One such teacher was Bill Clarkson. His book called 'Unique Perspectives' is an inspirational account about how to develop students 'voice in writing and content studies. His work in turn was inspired by earlier creative teachers; this is the way real ideas are spread in education.

A creative classroom, according to Bill, must value and respect the ideas, viewpoints and interests of the students.

Such a classroom requires that students are, 'genuinely engaged in their learning and pursuing things that are of interest or of importance to them', and if this is the case, 'the way they respond to and express their ideas will be unique'.

What is crucial, Bill believes, is that the learner develops as, 'an independent and creative thinking individuals in control of their own identity and their chosen path in life'. The 'life blood' of such an individual, 'is the strength of the child's voice'.

To achieve this requires an environment that,'taps into the children's natural curiosity about the world', an environment that contains, 'opportunities for experiencing all the different ways of learning; first hand experience, observing,drawing, thinking, talking, listening, reading, calculating and investigating'.

'All dialogue between the teachers and the child in the context of any kind of writing must be sensitive to the child's purpose or voice'. Bill's book is full of examples of both poetic and research writing that reflect student's voice' and creativity, along with art and photographs.

'It is also important that topics selected by the teachers are flexible enough to allow individual interpretation and direction'. Even in a shared experience that is narrower, such as a class observing a kingfisher diving for food, it still remains important that a teacher does not have too much influence on the control of the writing '(or drawing); it is important that children write not to please the teacher but to, 'develop original and honest thought'. It is also important for children to, 'be given time think through and interpret', before they express their ideas.

Quality work, in any area, takes time and thought. If a thing is worth doing it is worth doing well.

Bill believes strongly in students exploring the immediate environment;'Students from an early age are fascinated and naturally curious about the world outside'. Students , Bill writes, 'cannot be expected to develop a strong sense of place, or real appreciation of where they live, if they are not given the opportunity to explore their immediate and local environment.They should know about the significance of the the old buildings, pa sites, or monuments down the road, and be able to investigate the significant aspects of the natural environment such as a nearby patch of bush'.

To do so teachers , 'need to be seriously involved in teaching the students the skills and attitudes needed to permit focused and intensive' study. Students need to understand the purpose of any study and be able to make use of their senses to 'experience with vividness and freshness'.

Bill strongly believes in teachers coming alongside the learner to really listen to what they think and and have to say: 'From the teachers point of view this requires a genuine desire to know what a child thinks and why', to, 'help children develop, clarify, modify and extend their ideas' , and to help them explore,'ways to communicate these ideas honestly and effectively'.

Such honest 'interactive dialogue' requires that students and teacher trust and respect each other. Such a dialogue creates an environment that frees and challenges children to confidently do their thinking out loud and then for the teacher to sensitively and respectfully respond to their perceived learning needs.'

The students in Bill's classroom not only produced work reflecting personal 'voice' and in depth thinking but it was always presented in ways that reflected its importance. The walls of the classroom clearly showed student creativity and thinking, based on current topics, and student book and research work illustrated an emphasis on personal excellence and 'pride of achievement'. Procedures were introduced to assist students but students were always encouraged to 'personalise' their work as necessary. Final products represent a, 'labour of love and the tangible reward', of a job well done. The way teachers display children's work is, 'a direct message to students about how much the teacher values or respects their work.'

Bill concludes his book with the argument that, 'there is a definite need to promote more personalised and responsive strategies in teaching', and that the , 'strength of ( student) voice, sincerity and genuine quality is at stake'.

Teachers who do not have a copy of this book are missing a great example of a teacher who was able to engage the minds and hearts of his students; a teacher who was able to inspire even the most reluctant students to value their own identity, 'voice' and creativity.

Teachers who really believe that their students ought to be , 'seekers, users, and creators' , of their own learning would find the book both inspirational and practical.

Contact me( bhammonds@clear.net.nz) if you would like a copy.

Sunday, March 16, 2008

Asterix theory of talent development

Asterix, a Gosginny and Udeno cartoon about a defiant tribe of Gauls resisting the might of the Roman Empire.


Over the centuries the view about which counts for more, heredity or nurture, has concerned thinkers. Whatever view is held makes a great difference to the assumptions underpinning society and, in particular, education. A view of the mind as a 'blank slate' places the emphasis on the environment, or nurture, while an emphasis on nature places the emphasis on the genetic heredity of the individual.

In recent book, 'Nature Via Nurture' by Matt Ridley, both, he writes, contribute to whoever we are to become; the emphasis is on 'nature via nurture' . The book is a great read but I was attracted by his thoughts about how the environment young people grow up in effects the development of each persons unique talents.

Children do not see themselves as apprentice adults, he writes, but rather they try to be as good as they can be whatever their age. What they want to do is to find a niche within their group of peers, conforming to expectations on one hand, while at the same time differentiating themselves on the other. Developing this balance is a continuing universal challenge for us all.

Anthropologists believe that ancestral human being reared their young in groups; their natural habitat being a mixed age creche. This is believed is a more natural habit than the more recent and much admired isolated nuclear family.

In early, or pre- industrial, cultures young children found themselves searching for appropriate roles in relation to their peers. Peer pressure ought not to be seen as a negative influence, as it often is, as it has a major effect on student behaviour and can be utilized positively. This search for identity amongst ones peers still underpins student behaviour in modern classrooms and, as such, it is one that we ,as teachers, ought to be more aware of.

Examining any young group, in the past, out of school, in families, or in the classroom, and you will see, says Ridley, 'a tough, a wit, a brain, a leader, a beauty'.'Each child soon realizes what he or she is good at and what he or she is bad at- compared with the others in the group. He then trains for for that role and not for others, acting in character, developing still further the talent he has and neglecting the talent he lacks. The tough get tougher, the wit gets funnier, and so on. By specialising in the role he has chosen, he becomes what he is good at.'

An awareness of this role differentiation occurs about the age of eight - before this age all young children believe they are artists, after eight certain 'artistic' individuals are nominated by their peers.

It would seem important, if this is the case, that children are given every opportunity to develop, amplify, or discover what talents they might be good at and to encourage more positive roles, if a learning disposition is to be nurtured. Small differences can be magnified by habit and acceptance. The teacher's role ought to be to develop a positive and challenging learning environment that continually widens the students' horizons, building on their innate propensities.

Ridley calls this the Asterisk theory of human personality. In the well known cartoon, about a Gaul village resisting the Roman Empire, there is a very neatly drawn set of roles.

The village comprises of a strong man ( Obelix), a chief ( Vitalstatisitix), a druid ( Gestafix), a bard ( Cacophenix), a blacksmith ( Fulliautomix), a fishmonger( Unhygenix) and a man with bright ideas ( Asterix). The harmony of the vilage owees something to the fact that each man respects the others talents - with the exception of Cacophonix, the bard whose songs are universally dreaded.

No human being is rich in all talents in the same way but all have potential talents to develop as has been explored by Howard Gardner in his theory of multiple intelligences.

All viable communities, including schools, and individual classrooms, thrive because of the respect of each others talents and a willingness to share and help each other; this trust and cooperation is to each others mutual benefit.

The trouble , according to Ridley, is that modern industrial society people are assigned jobs without respect for talent. Not surprising, since in school developed in an industrial era, one size had to fit all.

'Personalised learning' is an antidote to such a wasteful but efficient mass system.

We need, as in early human cultures, to take advantage of each persons natural talent as and reinforce nature with nurture ( by providing opportunity and focused practice), so each persons innate talent becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

Given the right conditions we all get good at what we get good at- and avoid what we don't do so well. Children, when they experience success, in whatever area, have their appetite sharpened for that thing.

Any ability, from making music to playing golf, is a mixture of nature and nurture. Often all that is need is a slight aptitude and an appetite for endless practice. The skill of a mentor, or coach, makes a big difference to gaining success. Such success gains the respect of others - more so if the expertise is utilised for the common good .

Lessons in all this for creative schools and teachers?. Our society is full of, 'round pegs in square holes'.

Thursday, March 13, 2008

Edutopia



If you want to gain insight into project based learning then take a look at this Edutopia article and then visit site to see if you can find a series of wonderful small videos based on real life investigations at all levels of the school.

This is the George Lucas ( of Star Wars fame) educational site which features real life cross curricular learning integrating information technology.

Wherever you end up on the site it will be well worth the effort.

While you're there join up for the Edutopia free newsletter.

Edutopia is all about inquiry learning where students become, 'seekers, users and creators of their own knowledge' that the 'new' New Zealand Curriculum is all about.

For more about Project Based Learning and even more.

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

A wider view of Literacy

After exploring, students 'prior ideas' and questions about ANZAC Day, class discussions, and researching articles and pictures, students drafted out, and wrote up, their own thoughts. The challenge included appropriately illustrating the topic. A range of skills ( 'literacies') need to be in place to complete such a task.

The 'new' New Zealand Curriculum asks schools to develop: 'Students who are competent thinkers and problem solvers (who) actively seek, use and create knowledge.They reflect on their own learning, draw on personal knowledge and intuition, ask questions, and challenge the basis of assumptions and perceptions.'

In the future this what classroom, and student research, should reflect at all levels.

To do this it is important for students to be motivated by 'real life', meaningful challenges from across the curriculum that make use of whatever Learning Areas( disciplines) are required.

It would seem obvious that literacy ( and where possible numeracy) programmes should be integrated with current class studies. Students need, the curriculum says, to be able to , 'critically interrogate texts', and to, 'receive, process and present ideas or information'.

Students need both to 'make meaning' of ideas or information as well as 'creating their own meanings' from such information.

A close read of many current student research presentations would show that this is not being achieved. There is little of the tentative , 'I think', 'it could be', 'this suggests'; phrases that show students own 'voice', rather than 'cutting and pasting'.

Students need to be taught stages in research writing following their investigations. They need to be able to focus their research on a few key questions, and to take notes about ideas they feel relevant to their queries. They also need to be shown a organisational format to assist them present their ideas - essentially, their study question, possibly their current thinking or 'prior ideas',their research, and data and finally conclusions and references

They also need to be taught a range of design and presentation formats suitable for the students ages. If a booklet is to be produced of their findings, each page needs to be thought through carefully, including any illustrations and graphical data.

Such design skills are best taught by means of student exercise books which offers a means for each students to observe their growth, both in presentation and content.

That teaching such information gathering and interpreting skills are important is reflected by a recent Nationwide survey that showed that the current workforce is lacking in such skills. The lack of interpretive literacy and numeracy skills suggest a greater emphasis on the applied use of them in the school system. And the earlier the better.

Literacy and numeracy are integral to ensuring students are their own users, seekers, and creators' and to create schools as 'communities of inquiry'; tapping the intellectually curiosity of students.

And developing exciting student studies is the key to achieving this. The 'new' curriculum wisely suggests that students need to do 'fewer thing well' so as to develop this, all to often missing,in-depth thinking.

I look forward to seeing this depth of thought being a feature in classrooms I visit.

Monday, March 10, 2008

A new personal focus



I started this blog to express my opinions about the faulty thinking that underpinned the previous New Zealand Curriculum and to share creative alternatives.

The previous curriculum, with all its: Learning Areas , strands, levels, and countless learning objectives, was 'a mile wide and an inch deep'. It was, from the beginning, an incoherent and impossible ask. I was surprised that so many schools even tried to implement it but, I guess, they has no choice but to comply . Some principals, it has to be said, seemed to enjoyed the managerial emphasis!

Creative schools, of course, 'colonized' it to suit themselves. This is as it should be but it has been wasted decades as far as creative education has been concerned. It is to the credit of those schools that have persevered with innovative ideas in such a time of compliance, conformity , top down control and imposed ideas.

But it hasn't been easy for creative teachers or principals in such a risk averse environment.

The 'new' New Zealand Curriculum, combined with a personalised learning agenda, provides a great opportunity to return to a more creative education.

So now I see my self appointed role as one of encouraging schools to take advantage of the new opportunities.

The trouble is that too many school have 'accepted' the previous curriculum as their 'default' position and, in particular, the development of an emphasis on a 'Victorian' literacy and numeracy curriculum. This was encouraged by a Ministry insistence on 'target setting' in these areas.

Nothing wrong with literacy and numeracy but they are, at best, 'foundation skills' required to be in place to allow students to engage in activities that have the power to develop their gifts and talents. 'Learnacy' is more important than literacy and numeracy; or the 'key competencies', in the jargon of the new curriculum.

Literacy and numeracy will never be enough to equip students for the future. For schools to spend well over half their time on these areas is to put their students futures at risk.

The future will be driven by a creative imperative and will citizens with a passion to learn things in line with their innate talents, as well as a desire to continue learning forever.

Recognising, developing and, and amplifying these talents, is the role of future orientated 'learning advisers'.This is something creative teachers have aways known -'to see things in the seed, that is genius' ( Lao Tzu).

Our 'new' curriculum re-surfaces ideas lost in the past technocratic, industrial age, 'top down' decades. A positive learning identity, based on personal strengths, now needs to be the right of all students.

Our 'new' curriculum asks teachers to see their students as, 'active seekers, users and creators of their own knowledge'.It asks for this a to be developed by engaging students in real life integrated learning contexts. And these, it states, need both the time to develop a depth of understanding , and a need to do fewer things well. Future students will need not just 'foundation skills' , a depth of knowledge and understanding, as well as the life long 'key competencies'.

This is sadly lacking in the schools I visit. Other than literacy and numeracy the remainder of the curriculum is, all too often, reduced to shallow studies that only give a colourful surface impression to visitors.

Future schools need to become 'communities of inquiry' where all learners are continually challenged to expand their fields of learning. There ought to be more questions than answers, and what answers there are, are ought to reflect the tentativeness of new learning, not mere 'cutting and pasting'.

My own background as adviser has given me an appreciation of the various passions that motivates the various advisers; my experience as science adviser has helped me appreciate the power of interest in learning and the importance of valuing student's own thinking; and as an art adviser I have learnt the importance of the creative process (as 'messy' as it often is) as well as the importance of completing any creative task, as well as one can, so as to gain the necessary pride of achievement to continue learning.

Our 'new' curriculum is now in line with my own thinking and with the creative teachers of the past - for those, with long memories, it is, 'back to the future'!

So far, however, I see little evidence that schools have as yet taken the creative opportunities that lie before them.
Sharing creative teachers' ideas is the only way to spread valuable ideas. Our website,this blog,and my booklets, are ways of doing this.

Of course many teachers may feel that they are already achieving the curriculum's intentions - self delusion is one way of avoiding real change.

To confirm reality look around classrooms for evidence of in-depth studies and creative expression . By now school walls, children's study books, and computer portfolios, ought to be showing improving examples of such idiosyncratic thinking .This is the real 'evidence based' teaching. Or is what to be seen formulaic and conformist?

The challenge for primary schools is to see past their literacy and numeracy programmes and to focus on creating the conditions to realise the talents of all their students. And then to assist them in developing their individual competences in ways only just beginning to be imagined.

Secondary schools have the seemingly impossible challenge to transform their entire system so to change from industrial aged academic institution to twenty first century learning communities. Their challenge is to move away from , 'one size fits all', so as to personalise learning opportunities for all their students - or be bi-passed in the process by modern information technology.

The revolution is starting but to gain a foothold in the future but to succed we need to link up with other teachers and other schools so as to take advantage of our shared strengths, and also to give us the courage to really push the boundaries.

Such changes will be hard fought. The 'status quo' has a powerful resistance to change. Developing new ideas is never easy, only exciting.

I look forward to helping as best I can

This is my 'revised' agenda.

Tuesday, March 04, 2008

Time for some choices?

















Creativity or conformity?

Time to leave the corrosive age of accountability and enter a new era of creativity.

We need new minds for a new millennium.

Time for courageous leadership.



Around the world their is a rising tide of disquiet about the distorting results of an over emphasis on the time spent on reading and maths and, as a result, the squeezing out of other equally important aspects of education.

The accountability movement hasn't thankfully reached the oppressive levels in New Zealand as it has in America, the United Kingdom ( with its league tables) and even in our close neighbour Australia.

But a look at our primary schools would show that literacy and numeracy have, as one UK commentator says, ' all but gobbled up the rest of the curriculum'.

The fact of this emphasis on literacy and maths targets has been a narrowing of the curriculum and we are paying price for this narrowing. In countries overseas there have been dramatic cuts in such intellectually rich subjects as social studies, the arts, physical education and even science.

Such a distortion has the effect of not valuing and amplifying the various talents of students in the neglected fields. The very talents we desperately need as a country to thrive in the 21stC.

Our 'new' Zealand Curriculum, which states that we want to see our students as , 'seekers, users and creators of their own knowledge', gives us a choice to redress the balance.

Currently New Zealand schools, unlike other countries, select their own achievement targets but for all the choice these are , in the main, restricted to literacy and numeracy. And what get measured gets done and takes up the prime time; other areas get pushed to the margins. The so called 'achievement gap' is restricted to reading and maths - if the only game in town is soccer its tough if you are a hockey player! Our New Zealand Curriculum states that every student can learn - something our system so far has never achieved.

Sometimes it seems it is too difficult to simply find the time to do more exiting programmes.

What really matters ought to be the passions, talents, motivation and aptitudes of our students - their openness and excitement for learning. What our 'new' curriculum calls 'key competencies'.

We need to redress the situation by valuing the 'creative spirit' within every learner.

This is the choice our 'new' curriculum offers us. We no longer have to worry about 'coverage' but we need to 'design ' challenges that that provide all students the opportunity to develop their innate competencies and talents. The curriculum, suggests wisely, that we should do fewer things, to do them in depth, and to integrate, where possible, learning areas.

Seeing each student as an individual and then doing our best to help them to be the best they can be ought to be the new emphasis. Some call this emphasis 'personalised learning' as against, 'one size fits all'.

Such a creative emphasis requires equally creative teachers.

Creating the conditions to encourage teacher creativity is the challenge of leadership at all levels. Relationships and trust need to replace compliance and control.

A creative education, where students work collaboratively, develops in students a capacity for empathy and collaborative work as well as self managing skills.

A creative education provides to all students ( not just the academic), by recognising and developing their talents, a sense of direction and purpose in their lives.

A creative education develops flexible thinking and risk taking in students, important elements in an individuals future success.

Such ideas take us well beyond traditional secondary schools with their academic bias and separate subjects and primary schools that have over emphasized literacy and numeracy.

So there are choices of direction to be made.

Our society is going through a time of dramatic change in every area of life and new thinking will be required if our planet is to remain conducive to human life.

A creative education is, in a way, a spiritual one - one of developing personal meaning in life. It is about emphasizing the important values rather than narrow achievement targets. The future is not just about literacy and numeracy ( so important in an industrial age) but it more about 'learnacy'; the love of learning itself.

It is all about connecting people to a larger narrative than their own lives.

Our young people must acquire a 21st century education - one that faces up the reality of our own fragile existance.

But first we, as teachers, must make the right choices.

Monday, March 03, 2008

Losing the art of play














Are young children too busy 'achieving' to play?

Early childhood programmes are being set up in America to 'teach' children to play!

The reasoning behind such programmes is that today's young people are too busy to play ( being taken to endless classes by their ambitious parents). Or, just as bad , according to New Zealander Brian Sutton -Smith ( a world wide expert on children's play and games), is the image of isolated play - of young children sitting alone in front of a screen.

A cultural historian, Howard Chudwell, believes that from 1955 , due to the marketing of toys, children's play became focused on the toys themselves. Toys have replaced imaginative improvised activity as the focus of play. New commercial toys provide restricted scripts 'shrinking the size of children's imaginative space' -and owning such toys becomes all important.

Modern parents are increasingly becoming concerned about safety and prefer their children to 'play' in secure safe environments or classes; add to this middle class parents obsession for their children to succeed and free play is seen as waste of time. Such parents prefer extra work for their children on 'learning fundamentals' so as to get ahead.

Psychologist, Elena Bodrova, has researched children's diminishing capacity for self regulation, 'Today's 5 year olds were acting at the level of 3 year olds 60 years ago, and today's 7 year olds were hardly approaching the level of a 5 year old 60 years ago...the results are very sad'.

In earlier times young children played in groups engaging in free wheeling imaginative play, often being 'supervised' by older children.They were pirates or princesses, heroes and villains. While this play might have looked like time spent doing not much at all it built up all sorts of social and thinking skills. What the 'Tools of the Mind' call 'executive functions' including 'working memory and cognitive functions'. The most important being 'self regulation' - the ability for kids 'to control their emotions and behaviour, resist impulses, and exert self control and discipline.' This also includes resiliency - the ability to bounce back after setbacks that occur naturally while playing.

The lack of this ability to self regulate ones behaviour and demonstrate resiliency is associated with high school dropout rates, drugs and crime rates -'good executive behaviour is a better predictor than a child's IQ'.

The changing nature of play means that today's young children are not developing the executive self regulating behaviour they used to, according to many psychological researchers.

This is the reasoning behind the establishing in America of the 'Tools Of the Mind' programmes.

It seems to me that the cure is almost bad as the problem. Young children are being asked to think about their learning 'intentions' and then to write and draw what they plan to achieve during their programmed play!

I guess it is preferable to early childhood centres that are based on inappropriate age based academic programmes in order to push students to achieve. Some call such centres 'kinder factories' where students are directed to endless literacy and numeracy activities.

In 'mind 'tools' centres children are asked the question of the week and 'play games to develop the missing 'executive ' processes to help children learn to listen and control impulsive behaviours. Not even recces is fun, children are asked, 'What do they want to do, and how do they want to do it?' It is suggested that this lack of self regulation shows up in the growing number of students with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.

Play has never seemed more like work!

Well planned developmentally appropriate programmes, one would have thought, would be the answer. According to Thomas Armstrong , in his book 'Best Schools', believes that lots of free play is the best form of learning for young children and that such play is in line with early brain development. The idea of structuring every minute of a child's time must be stressful for the teachers involved.

The best kind of play costs nothing and only has one main requirement - imagination. When children play together, improvising, making things up, exploring, playing games, they are developing the all important self regulation behaviours. Such activities naturally involve children in facing up to choices and consequences, and to consider others if they want to have as much fun (learning) as possible.

Adults of course play an important role in establishing the conditions and material to entice students to play ( learn) together and their intervention's, if sensitive, are valuable.

There must be line between the structured play of 'Mindtools' and free play - particularly if young children are missing vital 'executive functions'. Well trained teachers will aways be needed to provide learning experiences and to help the students develop appropriate learning habits.

What is required is for students to become so involved that they learn the advantage of sustained concentration rather than flitting form activity to activity. Ensuring students develop such intelligent behaviours is the task of the teacher but does it need to be formalised to pre-planning everything? All children gain pride from doing things well but, in their hurried lives, they often do not have the encouragement or the time. When children want to do something well then this is the time for a bit of help from an adult.

Many teacher of young children in New Zealand express a worry that their students find it hard to keep on task at school and that children with some form of attention deficit disorder are almost epidemic.

Developmentally appropriate programmes, that stimulate, enrich and encourage 'self regulatory' behaviours ought to be a greater priority than literacy and numeracy before overly structured play becomes the new thing to do in New Zealand.

I am all for more play and creativity - activities that lead to the on uncovering of every learners' talents, gifts and passions.

Thursday, February 28, 2008

Back to the future.

Bill Guild working with students 25 years ago.

Twenty five years after retiring Bill Guild has been invited back to his old school to share his ideas about quality teaching and learning. It is a half a century since Bill took up his appointment at the school.

As well, it turns out, Bill taught the aunt of the current principal who wants to learn about, from Bill, the ideas that first gained the school it's creative reputation. Tapping into the wisdom of the past is a powerful idea - and it turns out Bill's wisdom is very current.

Bill was part of a small group of teachers who worked hard to develop creative classrooms in the 1970s. Today the challenge is for whole schools to work together to share their expertise.

When Bill retired he gave me notes of talks he had given and, in this this blog, I share a few of his ideas to indicate the thinking of the day.

'To me the teachers' role is vastly different.No longer the font of all knowledge but rather a counsellor, adviser, partner, guide, questioner, prompter and confidant.'

'I believe that schools must be learning communities where students learn, with our assistance, the things they want to learn; when they want to learn them; how they want to learn them; and why they want to learn them; all through their own curiosity'.

'As a group we were disillusioned with the traditional pre-packaged approach ...largely adult conceived....including ability grouping.Attributes such as co-operation, understanding and sharing were largely given lip service. We believed that learning should stem from the natural but vital curiosity of children and it should centre around real experiences'.

'Skills...such as focus, concentration, craftsmanship, introspection and independent inquiry need to be introduced.' 'Presentation and display skills need extra special attention and the creative areas given new emphasis.' We felt such independent self motivated learners would be more able to cope with the future with assurance and zest.People who are responsible for their own learning, able to make relevant choices, seem to be the kinds of people best suited to cope with future society.'

'To achieve work of high quality, which gives satisfaction and a feeling of personal success, there is a need to slow down the pace of work so the enjoyment is experienced as the work progresses and the finished piece reflects, not only thought, but pride of craftsmanship.Slowing down the working pace of children and allowing them time to reflect and and saviour their discoveries and achievements.'

'The role of the teacher is to encourage and stimulate pupils to seek knowledge for themselves.'

'Carefully arranged teacher displays', are a feature, and were based on, 'environmental, language, or maths topics'.'As the topic progresses the work of children is added to the display until it becomes an amalgam of both the children and the teachers efforts.' 'It is most important to acknowledge, in a meaningful way, the value of a piece of work.' 'These displays provide a window to the world revealing the work being done in literature, individual interests, the environmental and experiences shared by the class or as individuals.'

'There is an emphasis on the immediate environment.It is the teachers role to reveal the unknown in the familiar and to help children to discover the unnoticed world within their environment.' However, the interests of the children cover a wide range from fact to fantasy.' 'The school is a base from which to explore their environment.'

'Gradually, with experience and growing confidence in their own abilities, children are given some choice within a very wide topic and finally many children may reach a stage they can be given a complete choice.'

'Questioning techniques must be suited to the needs of the learner ...and should be framed in a way as to stimulate greater powers of thought.' 'Plenty of time must be given the children to talk, discuss,disagree, argue, and revise opinions, all of this while refining and defining their solutions.'

'Teaching observation is important. I believe we look at so much and see so little.Hence my belief that if we slow down our pace and allow ourselves the gift of observation.''Without the input of looking ..no future artistic or intellectual output is possible.' 'But drawings must go further than factual information, they are also able to convey feelings, impressions, and emotion.People who look harder, see more and understand more.' 'Drawing is a way of asking questions and drawing answers.'

Drawing involves the, 'outward eye, which is our observing eye, and an inward eye, which looks at feelings, memory, and imagination.' 'Observational drawing is not concerned with mere reproduction'... but result in, ' drawings which are uniquely yours.'

' A sense of design and beauty is an obvious need in our society and very little emphasis, and even scarcer recognition, has been placed on this area of visual education,'

Along with my colleagues I have tried to develop classroom programmes where children are exposed to a variety of ideas and situations.We have tried to take into account the backgrounds and interests of the children as well as they ways in which they learn. All children need success and we feel that this best achieved by children having confidence in themselves to select their own tasks, and through the development of necessary skills and abilities, to complete them to a deep sense of satisfaction in a task well done.'

Bill worked with group of creative classroom teachers working in different schoools. The challenge today is for whole schools and, better still, groups of creative schools working together making use of the teacher expertise in their own schools. And also, as Bill illustrates, the wisdom of past creative teachers.

The 'new' NZ curriculum provides an opportunity for the beginning of new creative era of education.

Monday, February 25, 2008

Learning styles

Classroom management and the four basic types of learners: Heart, head, hands, and the mind's eye.


In traditional teaching teachers presented their ideas to the whole class. Those who were aligned to the teacher's style managed to retain enough of whatever was presented to succeed . 'Successful' students, in such a academic environment, were those were those successful in the linguistic and logical- mathematical areas of learning.

Today, with an appreciation of the diversity of student learning styles, the idea of multiple intelligences, the modern emphasis on active learning, and the need for all students to gain success, such a simplistic pedagogy will no longer do.

Developing a 'personalised learning' approach, tailoring learning to the needs of each students ( as against the 'one size fits all'), is not as easy as it sounds. In the real world, outside of school, people make use of whatever ways of learning that do the job. For many such people school learning is of little use to them.

Developing a 'personalised approach' begs the question of, 'What do we do with the others?' Many teachers of junior classes have already solved this problem - group work - but all too often this resorts to ability grouping which goes against the premise of personalised learning. In secondary schools students are often 'streamed' to assist teachers cope with diversity but this is, all too often, at the expense of the so called 'slower' learners ( the less academic). 'Once a weka always a weka'!

By using a mixture of learning styles and group work all students can be assisted to achieve a high level of in-depth learning.

The four styles are :

1 The Interpersonal Style ( represented by a heart).This conversational style allows the teacher an opportunity to listen to the views of the students as in sharing a 'big book' with readers but it could equally be a science discussion to access 'prior idea' or learn from, and how to write up, an experiment.

2 The Thinking- Reasoning Style ( represented by the head). Students research ideas, using key question and appropriate resources, to extend their understanding -and possibly to develop further questions.

3 The Mastery Style ( represented by the hand). This group features making or doing. Practical 'hands on' tasks.

4 The Imaginative Style(represented by the minds eye).This group is involved in tasks extending the ideas imaginatively, making use of various forms of expression and media.

The above groups styles fits comfortably with the 'multiple intelligences' of Howard Gardener that many teacher make use of. Gardner believes that students need rich topics that utilize the appropriate intelligences. This idea also aligns well with an integrated approach making use of in depth knowledge from the various disciplines. The key is to do fewer things well - to study a topic in-depth.

When teachers plan their studies to cover all learning styles (and intelligences) it allows success to be a reality for all students. The four group styles are to be seen in any primary reading programme although, as mentioned, these are still ability groups.

In a class setting a topic could be introduced in week one. Students initial questions can be gained and their 'prior ideas', answering such questions, noted. Ideas for activities, and ways of communicating findings, could be discussed. Experiences could be introduced to provide background material for the students to think about.

Before the next week teachers could pull idea together and assign to the four group task for students to rotate around. This rotation might last up to two weeks making use of an hour a day; four sessions a week. Skills required in group work need to be taught prior to the tasks e.g. how to write up their research, or how to use the digital camera. Group work is not the time to teach new skills. Such skills could be taught in the language programme. Special attention needs to placed on assisting students develop design/presentation skills. Some schools develop design 'scaffolds' to assist students.

All the groups could contribute ideas to place on students completed booklet or web page etc; or they could be stand alone tasks.

By the end of the third or fourth week students would be expected to completed all tasks and then to evaluate and share negotiated tasks with others in the class, or their parents. By now the wall displays will feature the key questions and completed research tasks, art and creative language.

Such a group programme allows students a variety of opportunities to develop and share their talents. Not all students enjoy all styles but all need to experience the insight each offers.

It is best to keep group task specific and to encourage doing things well rather than rushing through task with an, 'I'm finished - first is best', attitude. Extra extension activities can be included for those 'fast finishers'.

When a group work pattern is established students will be able to apply themselves more positively and teachers will be able to find the time to interact with students to challenge, give encouragement and assess progress.

As time progress students will be able to see what their preferred styles are along with a growing awareness of the particular talents and strengths they have.

At this point 'personalisation' of learning is a real possibility.

For further ideas. Booklets 4 and 5

Friday, February 22, 2008

Developing an Inquiry Approach across the curriculum

Developing the school as a 'community of inquiry' is a theme running through the 'new' New Zealand Curriculum.


All learning is based on curiosity - a need to make personal meaning.It would be a great idea for schools to develop a inquiry approach across the curriculum that all teachers and students are able to articulate.

Not that there needs to be cut and tried approach ( all Learning Areas have their particular emphasis) but more that the spirit of inquiry should underpin all actions.

Some scientists prefer to call scientific thinking 'enlightened trial and error' - trying things out and keeping what works for 'next time'. Homer Simpson has the opposite point of view, 'Trying is just the first step towards failure'. In contrast basketballer Michael Jordan says, 'I've tried over and over again in my life and that is why I succeed.' Effort, practice,'stick-ability', or perseverance, are all important attributes

The New Zealand Curriculum, states in it's section in the Thinking Key Competency, that students need to be seen as, 'active, seekers, users and creators of knowledge'. Learning is to be, 'constructed', driven by, 'intellectual curiosity', as the students are encouraged to ,'ask questions,and challenge the basis of their assumptions and perceptions'

Under the Managing Self competency it is stated that, students need to have a, 'can do' attitude, able to , 'establish personal goals, make plans, (and) manage projects.'

Under the English Learning Area it states that, students need to be able to, 'make meaning of ideas or information'; in the Arts area students are, 'to use their imagination to engage' in expressing their interpretations; in Mathematics, 'students are to develop the ability to think creativity, critically, strategically and logically' and to carry our procedures, 'flexibly and accurately to process and communicate information'; Science includes students, 'making observations and carrying out investigations'; while in the Social Sciences students are to: ask questions, gather information, explore and analyze, and reflect and evaluate their learning. Technology is about designing products' and states that it is better to do fewer things well in depth.

The inquiry emphasis is highlighted in the Effective Pedagogy section where teachers are asked to help their students in the ability to, 'assimilate new learning, relate it to what they already know ( their 'prior knowledge') and learn to think about their own thinking' ( 'meta cognition'). Effective teachers are to, 'stimulate the curiosity of their students, require them to search for relevant information and ideas, and challenge them to use or apply what they discover' by means of 'learning conversations'.

With all the above in mind it is a wonder that Inquiry Learning didn't have section of its own?

Essentially Inquiry learning follows the following process ( remembering learning is not a linear sequence and that new ideas can emerge at any stage that could alter the course of the learning.)

1 A question or challenge arises that requires action to explore.( At this early stage it is a good idea for students to express what they already know - their 'prior ideas').

2 Students sort out the key questions to research (as individuals or groups). Teachers need to gather relevant information and resources, and also to consider relevant experiences that might be useful to provide greater depth of understanding. Teachers need also to consider what 'big idea' they want their students to achieve from the study.)

3 Students to undertake observations, research possible answers to their question and to carry out activities and experiments that might offer them greater insight. Simple tests might need to set up

4 Students to draft ideas out and to then present them to others for critical evaluation.

If the essence of the inquiry approach is communicated to students at every appropriate time it will become ingrained and transferred from situation to situation. This is not to say some processes will be subject specific.

The essence of Inquiry Learning is to question everything and be open to new possibilities. A mind disciplined by inquiry considers all forms of evidence that validates new ideas and delivers deeper and more insightful understanding.