Friday, August 12, 2016

Education Readings: writing junk/ Smart goals?/ STEAM education and lots more for creative teachers



Compiled by

Allan Alach


I welcome suggested articles, so if you come across a gem, email it to me at allanalach@inspire.net.nz

Writing Junk
‘Mediocre writing starts with the wrong questions, and a focus on a set, proscribed structure and process encourages students to ask the wrong questions. Hammer them with writing templates, and
Junk writing
students start to see an essay as a slightly more involved fill in the blank exercise. "I have to have five paragraphs-- what can I use to fill up the five paragraph-sized blanks?" "I need three sentences to make a paragraph-- what can I use to fill in the the three sentence-shaped empty spaces." This gets you junk.’

Why We Need to Move Away from SMART Goals and Towards New Forms of Classroom Assessment
Use SMART goals? Maybe you should read this article.
‘We need to align our purpose. We can’t continue to restrict student assessments to a simplified, out-dated system and expect to prepare them for an ever-changing employment environment of complexity and “abundance.”’
 
It is hard to assess what really matters - we need new ways of assessment


Stop asking whether laptops improve learning outcomes
‘Simply having students using laptops for learning is not enough. It is the type of activities that are being used and the depth of learning that occurs that is important. The laptop is simply a window to the learning. If the “view” is poor, the results will be poor. If the view is rich and meaningful, the results will be rich and meaningful.’

What Makes an ‘Extreme Learner’?
A passion to learn
‘Cueva-Dabkoski is considered an “Extreme Learner,” a designation applied to just 12 individuals by the Institute for the Future, for her radical and gutsy approach to learning. Extreme Learners are self-directed, wide-ranging in their interests, comfortable with technology, and adept at building communities around their interests.’

Hands-Off Teaching Cultivates Metacognition
Kids teaching kids
‘All that thought goes into a lesson, and still there are students spacing out during class or seeming to fall behind. Working so hard and still not reaching every student can be frustrating. And you have no one to blame but yourself -- you're hogging all the best learning in your classroom.’




Contributed by Bruce Hammonds:

When We Listen to Students
‘As you are beginning to think about returning to school, I have a suggestion that can drastically impact your year (and it's simple): brainstorm questions to ask your students.
The kids right in front of us often have the most useful information within them -- information that can help us reach and teach them, help us engage them, and that can help us have a fantastic year together.’

3 Challenges As Hands-On, DIY Culture Moves Into Schools
‘This hands-on, DIY culture of inventors, tinkerers and hackers is inspiring adults and children alike to design and build everything from sailboats and apps to solar cars.And this fall, more of these chaotic workspaces, stocked with glue guns, drills and hammers, will be popping up in schools, too.But the maker movement faces some big hurdles as it pushes into classrooms.’

Using STEAM to reverse teacher-directed mindsets
‘Integrating content isn’t a new idea. Integrating STEAM, on the other hand, can take educators into uncharted territory while they work to master “learning by doing.” Teachers are more apt to teach the way they were taught, which means roughly 80% of teachers typically use a teacher-directed approach while introducing one subject matter at a time.
The first step to reversing a teacher-directed approach is to change this mindset from the top down:’

From Bruce’s ‘goldie oldies’ file:

The killing of creativity by the technocrats.
Meta man
‘I have become increasingly concerned about the use of a number of strategies as defined by John Hattie and promulgated by the contracted advisers spreading the word about his 'best practices'.Somehow, just because Hattie has amalgamated every piece of 'school effectiveness' research available ( mainly it seems from the USA) his findings, it seems, ought to be taken for read. The opposite ought to be the case - we need to be very wary of such so called 'meta research.'. More worrying however is that the approaches he is peddling is pushing into the background the home grown innovative creative learning centred philosophy that was once an important element in many classrooms.’


An idea whose time has come; schools and teachers working together
‘Principals who can share leadership with their teachers and then with other schools will be seen as the real future leaders. Crowther calls this 'parallel leadership' - connecting principals and teachers through mutual respect. Up until now, Hargreaves states, teachers have been marginalised but we all know a school is only as good as its teachers.’

What do good learners do?
A young Einstein
What do good students do? Be worth asking your students for their thoughts.
‘Postman and Weingartner in their book ‘Teaching as a Subversive Activity’ gives an excellent outline of a good learner.First, good learners have the confidence in their ability to learn. This does not mean they are not sometimes frustrated and discouraged. They are …..but they have a profound faith that they are capable of solving problems, and if they fail at one problem they are not incapacitated in confronting another.’

 Messages about education.
‘I have been reading an article on the web about the pressures being placed on young children and their teachers in the United States to achieve expectations set by standardized tests. In the process teachers have had to narrow their curriculum to ensure their school does well when results are published. And as well, I guess, they would be worried about their tenure?’


Current formulaic teaching.

Friday, August 05, 2016

Sir Ken Robinson/ Seymour Papert RIP : Logo and Lego / Milton Friedman / Emotional Intelligence

Education Readings

By Allan Alach


I welcome suggested articles, so if you come across a gem, email it to me at allanalach@inspire.net.nz

Seymour Papert – Logo, Lego and constructionism - RIP
Education lost one of its greatest people this week, with the death of Seymour Papert. His book “Mindstorms’ should be in every teacher’s library.
Seymour Papert
Donald Clark:
‘Seymour Papert was a constructionist (not to be confused with constructivist), who worked with Jean Piaget and built on his theories to redefine how education could function on a constructionist basis. The Logo programming language was a tool he wrote to support this approach to learning and he was been a stern critic of traditional schooling.’

Papert - in his own words
Steve Wheeler’s tribute:
‘He was a stern critic of instructional and didactic forms of education, and was a champion of student centred learning, active
engagement and creativity. These ideas will continue to inspire generations of educators to come, and his influence will not be dimmed by his passing.’

Papert sharing ideas
Daily Papert: Words and wisdom of Dr Seymour Papert
Over the years Will Richardson and Gary Stager have compiled a comprehensive site honouring the work of Papert and that provides access to a long list of his quotes and writings.  It is well worth exploring!

One Mother's Story: How Overemphasis on Standardized Tests Caused Her 9-Year-Old to Try to Hang Himself
This story by Marion Brady speaks for itself.
“…I received a note from my son's teacher telling me he’d failed the FCAT [Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test] by one point. The note said he’d have to take a reading class over the summer and retest…We weren’t alarmed as he only had to score one more point to be promoted…’

Milton Friedman's Vision
For the rich only!
If you’re wondering where the current education ideology started, that led towards tragic stories like the one above, this will answer your questions.
‘Friedman's vision certainly has guided lots of folks in the past decade-plus, but he has also been proven wrong about pretty much everything. A choice system isn't cheaper, isn't better, and hasn't provided anything except profits for many of the privatizers. But at least he was absolutely clear about the goal-- turn public education into a private business, one way or another, and let folks make a bundle doing it.’

How to Bring ‘More Beautiful’ Questions Back to School
Everything starts with a great question… Einstein as a teenager wondered what it would be like to ride on a beam of light – 10 years or so later, he came up with the Theory of Relativity. He maintained he was just passionately curious – an ideal mindset to foster in children.
‘Curiosity is baked into the human experience. Between the ages of 2 and 5, kids ask on average 40,000 questions, said Warren Berger, author of  “A More Beautiful Question,” at the Innovative Learning Conference hosted at the Nueva School. Young kids encounter something new, learn a little bit about it, get curious and then continue to add on a little more information with each new discovery. Warren says that’s where curiosity happens, in the gap between learning something and being exposed to something new.’

Students published their book “Reflections”
This article about an e-book published by students in Texas and Vietnam isn’t strictly an education reading but then again it’s a very worthy cause.
‘This book is their labor of love. We facilitators have left their ideas, expression, and discoveries their own. The stories, the joy and sadness, the humor, the wonder, and the learning are their voices–a true Teenage Manifesto of the 21st century. We have learned much from them and hope you will, as well.’

Contributed by Bruce Hammonds:

The 1 Lesson That Will Sharpen Your Emotional Intelligence
Emotional Intelligence – the difference between empathy and sympathy.
To walk in someones shoes
‘Although most of us consider empathy a valuable and basic human trait, it often goes missing in day-to-day life. Just think of the major disconnect between many managers and their teams. Or how it's so easy to hurt those whom we love, simply because we can't see things from their perspective.’

Ken Robinson: 'You don't want a caste system for creativity’
‘Schools’ drive for conformity is at odds with the rapidly changing world, where being flexible, curious and creative are more important qualities than ever. Engendering these qualities in future generations matters to adland and the wider creative industries because they rely on a steady stream of diverse thinkers who can creatively solve business problems. Robinson’s talk, delivered with his quiet wit and charm, made waves. A decade on, it is still the most popular TED talk of all time, last week surpassing 40 million views. Combined with his later talks, he has racked up almost 60 million views without any paid media spend.’
 
School leader  agree with Sir Ken but few put his ideas into action!!!


Schools ride new wave in writing
Teachers use games and new tech tools to produce powerful prose.
‘“If you want kids to write about something challenging, you really need to put them in a position to discuss it first in an active, open-ended sort of way, because then they have something to write about,” Roberts says. It introduces them to the language they might use and the ideas they need to be able to manipulate to write with sophistication, Roberts adds.When students understand that the purpose of writing is to share ideas, they perform better than do students who are asked to write just for the sake of writing.’

From Bruce’s ‘goldie oldies’ file:

A little bit of deja vu
Henry Pluckrose
‘It is all too easy to think what currently passes for new ideas are really new - just another version of ideas often lost when top down 'experts' ignore the reality of true learning.’

Does your classroom have the 'wow' factor?
‘The first sign of ‘wow’ is the overall first impression the room gives you. The feeling you get is that you are indeed in special place. There is a feeling of positive relationships between teacher and learners and often parents are to be seen quietly helping students. Other students seem to be working without supervision. A quick look around the walls, covered with students creativity gives an impression that this is a room dedicated to the students themselves.’

The killing of creativity by the technocrats.
The killing of creativity by technocrats like John Hattie
‘Be careful when using the latest jargon: 'learning intentions', 'success criteria', 'WALTS', 'modelling' and'guided practice' or you will be leading your students to conformist learning and, in the process, limiting their innate individuality and creativity. As an antidote, at least, ensure that students appreciate the need for individual creativity and value their 'voice' in what they present.’


Teachers should assist with a light hand!

Wednesday, August 03, 2016

Creativity in education depends on the focus being returned to implementing the New Zealand Curriculum



Creative education in New Zealand is at risk.

It seems to me,from what I hear from friends still involved in teaching that education in New Zealand is in a  sorry position.

The big revolution  in education was introduced with Tomorrows Schools in the 80s when New Zealand schools were made 'self managing' as part of the neo-liberal ideology of the  government of the day  - sadly a Labour government. The changes were premised on the mantra 'good people poor system' so, after several decades, what's changed?

 In 2007 the then Labour government, realizing the error of their ways, introduced the current New Zealand Curriculum. Unfortunately the current National government has returned to the neo liberal  path with a vengeance.

At the time I thought  Tomorrows Schools  was  a good move. The idea of neighborhood schools, freed from the constraints of central government, seemed like democracy in action. The neo- liberal,, or 'market forces' ideology, was supposed to be all about allowing schools ( and other public services) to be more enterprising. Instead we have ended up with an oppressive  competitive compliance culture

Wiser people like Kelvin Smythe warned about consequences of such actions  at the time but he was ignored.  Kelvin to this day fights the good fight and I am now with him - and, it seems, his voice is still ignored by school principals who  see no alternative but to comply with government directives..

The most trenchant criticism of the direction the current government is taking schools feature in the NZPPF Magazine last year - could not have been clearer.

National Standards - the 'default' curriculum.

Now it is National Standards that determine education in our schools not the more liberal New Zealand Curriculum.  The Standards are now in many schools  the default curriculum





Time to return to implementing the New Zealand Curriculum


We now see schools  obsessed with ensuring their National Standards data ( and in Secondary schools NCEA Level 2 targets) are comparable with other schools. Sadly schools are gaming the system and the data lacks integrity. Kelvin Smythe, and other, have written about this.

The promise of democracy and creativity that some of us thought would eventuate has been all but  lost. The so called 'nanny state' has been replaced by a technocratic  'big brother' surveillance culture - a culture where the 'voice' of teachers have been deliberately ignored.  Teacher unions and principal groups have all but given up  expressing  a viable alternatives.

Communities of Schools or Communities of Control


The compliance culture
Currently the Ministry of Education is trying to impose Communities of Schools. The trouble is communities they aren't. Such school groups have to achieve approved targets and only schools in such groupings will receive professional development and development from Ministry approved sources.  This, added to the formulaic  'best practice' teaching will  crush any creativity and diversity that remains in our system. Privatization  of schools seems the direction the government wants to achieve. 

Currently their is now the misguided focus on Maori/Pacifica achievement - misguided because of the focus on assessing achievement determined by National Standards/NCEA Level 2 achievement  which ignore equally  important attributes and talents such students might have.

'If you judge a fish by its ability to 

climb a tree it will live its whole life believing it is stupid'. Einstein

So  what does the NZC  say?
ERO visit - comply or else!

With all this in mind it is time schools refocused their attention on the vision of the New Zealand Curriculum and in particular the 'first half' of the document. The focus in the NZC is  for schools to insure all students leave 'connected, actively involved, and lifelong learners'. National Standards will not achieve this vision.

'Seekers, users and creators of knowledge'.

For me the key aspects of being a lifelong learners is for students to be 'active seekers ,users and creators of knowledge'. School programmes need to place this at the centre of their programmes, or as the NZC says,  'place students at the centre of teaching and learning' by experiencing 'a curriculum that engages and challenges them'. and  a curriculum that 'ensures that students' identity, languages, abilities are recognized and affirmed.'

There is a need to 're-frame' literacy and numeracy.

A quick look at how schools use time  will indicate if the NZC is central to learning. It is my observation that the great portion of time in primary schools is given over to literacy and numeracy - as one commentator has said 'it is as if the evil twins of literacy and numeracy have gobbled up the entire curriculum'. This not to say such areas are unimportant, quite the opposite, it is just that they need to be re-framed as vital skills in the realization of authentic learning challenges.

It would be asking too much to integrate literacy and numeracy but at the very least it should be re framed and seen as an opportunity to introduce skills and content that contribute to the inquiry programme..
Junior ideas about shadows


The importance of the Key Competencies.

These are to be seen 'both an means and an end and the means other ends are achieved' and they are' to be developed over time'. The thinking competency is all about helping students 'make sense of information' ( a vital aspect of critical literacy) helping them 'constructing knowledge' and 'developing intellectual curiosity' by  ensuring all students can actively seek, use, and create knowledge'. A quick read of student work will indicate if this is so. All too often shallow  'cut and paste' is the name of the 'inquiry  game'.

Managing self is another key competency.  This is about developing students develop  ' a "can do" attitude so they see themselves as capable learners.

The importance of the Learning Areas.

With the current emphasis on National Standards studying Learning Area  content in depth, as part of class studies, can be to easily neglected. Students 'researching' using Google is not enough and all too often leads to shallow or fragile learning.  Every year students should experience a full range of the Learning Areas because such a range of experiences 'lays  a foundation for later specialization' and, more importantly, provides opportunities to value, amplify and uncover students interests and talents.
Science - a vital area

The NZC suggests that 'all learning should make of natural connections that exist between learning areas and  link learning areas to values and key competencies'. Schools could develop a range of studies that combine any number of strands from the appropriate learning areas.  Students, as they progress through school, should develop a positive appreciation of the essence of each area.

Whatever is chosen should be studied in depth,  negotiated with the students, students' questions valued  and their  prior ideas appreciated.

The English Learning Area ( encompassing literacy)  is 'fundamental to success across the curriculum and is all about  requiring students to 'receive, process, and present ideas or information'. English is about 'making meaning of ideas or information' and
Value student voice
'creating meaning for themselves'


A school developing such a programme is Mount Eden Normal. Island Bay is another such school.

An inquiry model  to integrate all learning areas.

Although there is not a section defining inquiry learning is  mentioned and integral to all learning areas. The essence of science is about 'investigating,  understanding and explaining' it involves 'generating and testing ideas gathering evidence' 'making observations and carrying out investigations'.

This problem solving inquiry model is  integral to all learning.  In the Arts Learning Area  the NZC states: ' ideas are  generated and refined through cycles of action and reflection';  in the Maths Learning Area   maths is to be seen as  a way 'of thinking and solving problems', and 'investigating, interpreting, explaining and making sense'. Maths is an area where students 'learn to create models and predict outcomes, to conjecture to justify and verify'. The Social Science Learning Area  has a similar inquiry approach. Students in this area are required to 'ask questions, gather information...to explore and analyse.. to consider .. and to reflect and evaluate'.

I would expect classrooms to reflect a diverse range of depth studies integrating, as appropriate, literacy and numeracy skills.

Effective Pedagogy is a vital section of the NZC.

Effective pedagogy includes 'enhancing the relevance of new learning'; 'makes connection to prior learning; and, most importantly, 'provides sufficient opportunities to learn'.

Opportunities to learn is the key to providing all learners with success  not National Standards or NCEA targets.

The effective pedagogy statement  emphasizes the importance of developing  a positive learning culture , seeing the class as 'a learning community', the need for  respectful relationships and the importance of 'encouraging reflective thought and action' .

 Advice is given to ' cover less but cover it in greater depth'.

Teaching as Inquiry ( TAI)

An inquiry model is outlined for teachers  to 'inquire into the impact of their teaching'. I would suggest that teachers inquire into how well the NZC is being implemented and in particular the various learning areas.

The School Curriculum.
Valuing the creative arts

To implement the vision of the NZC  requires 'a clear understanding of the intentions of the New Zealand Curriculum. 'All New Zealand students regardless of of where they are situated, should experience a rich and balanced education that embraces the intent of the New Zealand Curriculum'; and that the schools curriculum should respond to the 'particular needs, interest, and talents' of their students.

The NZC is based on the 'premise  that all students can learn and succeed' and that each learners ultimate learning success is more important than the covering of particular achievement objectives, and, I would add the National Standards.

Assessment

The excellent assessment section has been distorted by the  current reactionary and narrow  demands of the National Standards.

An  audit and surveillance culture is now  part of our school system and  has all but destroyed creativity and diversity in our schools and, in the process, the full implementation of the New Zealand Curriculum.


'The primary purpose of assessment is to improve students' learning' and that
assessment  'is best understood as on ongoing process that arises out of the interaction between teaching and learning'.

'Much of this evidence is 'of the moment" and  'often takes place in the mind of the teacher, who then uses the insights gained to shape their actions as they continue to work with their students.'


The 2007 New Zealand Curriculum has yet to be fully implemented – at best schools are tinkering around the edges – at worst totally distracted by the reactionary demands of National Standards.Jane Gilbert, in her book ‘Catching the Knowledge Wave’ NZCER reprinted 2008, writes, ‘we can’t do more of what we are currently doing… we cannot add new ideas to an old framework’. And adds we need to ‘develop a new public understanding about what we think and hope our education can do for people’.
Time to hunt out, dust down, re-read and implement creative vision of   the New Zealand  Curriculum before it is too late.





The alternative looks good to me!






.

Friday, July 29, 2016

Genius in education/ technology and learning Diane Ravitch/ project Based Learning/ Pokemon and much more


Education Readings



By Allan Alach


I welcome suggested articles, so if you come across a gem, email it to me at allanalach@inspire.net.nz

How to Get Started With Genius Hour for Elementary Classrooms?
Well worth trying in your classroom.
Genius hour
‘I believe that every single child is gifted and that every kid has a talent which we as educators should help uncover. This is not easy when you have a curriculum to follow and tons of material to teach. But that given we need to make time to work with kids in a different and more creative setting. It’s important to let them explore new things that may not be present in your curriculum but are in your students’ heads all the time. This is how we can awaken curiosity in young children and help them develop creative thinking.’

Idea to retire: Technology alone can improve student learning
‘Yet each successive wave of technology has failed to live up to its hype, and millions have been spent trying to make technology do what it, alone, cannot do. Ultimately, it is not the technology that does the teaching.  Technology is a tool that is wielded by people to accomplish specific ends.  While it can serve as an accelerator, it can just as easily accelerate poor strategies as effective ones.  It is the teaching approach—the pedagogy—that ultimately determines learning outcomes.  Once this is understood, a series of other misconceptions also fade.’

What Bruner Really Meant: a personal viewpoint
If you are a user of ‘WALTS’ or other learning outcome type procedure, I suggest you read this.
Jerome Bruner
‘The idea of starting with a learning objective is somewhat at odds with a constructivist approach, yet in far too many schools in the United Kingdom, teachers are still required to display just such an objective at the start of every lesson, despite there being no evidence that this achieves very much at all. Just to be clear, a learning objective is a good and important thing, but children are not mere machines – sometimes their thoughts will lead them ‘off script’ and they may make important connections and realisations that fall outside the narrow scope of an objective. Thus it is as pointless as showing them the end of a film before they have had a chance to work through the story and watch the plot develop.’

How Billionaires Are Successfully Fooling Us Into Destroying Public Education—and Why Privatization Is a Terrible Idea
Diane Ravitch
This is an extract from Diane Ravitch’s book “The Death and Life of the Great American School System.” While written about the USA, we can find the same things happen in many other countries, including New Zealand.
‘A powerful, well-funded, well-organized movement is seeking to privatize significant numbers of public schools and destroy the teaching profession. This movement is not a conspiracy; it operates in the open. But its goals are masked by deceptive rhetoric. It calls itself a “reform” movement, but its true goal is privatization.’

10 Ways Pokémon Go Augments Real-World Education & Student Learning
This week’s Pokémon Go article…
‘As with all sudden fads, a host of important caveats have emerged this past week, including safeguarding private information, respecting hallowed locations, and ensuring personal safety. Also, as with most fads, this one game will not revolutionize education. That being said, here are 10 ways that Pokémon Go can support the skills of contemporary learning:’

Early Academic Training Produces Long-Term Harm
An article by Peter Gray that discusses the  ‘school reform’ agenda of making very young children jump academic hurdles.
‘Research reveals negative effects of academic preschools and kindergartens.
The results are quite consistent from study to study:  Early academic training somewhat increases children’s immediate scores on the specific tests that the training is aimed at (no surprise), but these initial gains wash out within 1 to 3 years and, at least in some studies, are eventually reversed.  Perhaps more tragic than the lack of long-term academic advantage of early academic instruction is evidence that such instruction can produce long-term harm, especially in the realms of social and emotional development.’

Contributed by Bruce Hammonds:

We Don't Like “Projects"
Project based learning based on authentic inquiry lost in many schools – this applies to New Zealand schools
‘I uncovered some frankly stunning assumptions that many students have about learning:The word "project" is not a happy word. When I say project-based learning, most students grimace as they imagine prescribed PowerPoints;If a teacher doesn't plan it, it's not learning;If there isn't a test, it wasn't real.Their personal interests cannot inform their learning. Learning is sterile, and the actual usage of the word "learning," to them, is quite different from what a professional might consider learning.’

Secret Teacher: My pupils' creativity is being crushed by the punctuation police
Students creativity in writing being crushed- and its the case in New Zealand as well
‘The technocratic approach to assessment is supposed to be raising standards, but I do not see how. The children in my class have not become better writers this year. They haven’t had as many opportunities to be creative. They haven’t been able to focus on good story writing.’

Facing Resistance? Try a New Hat
Modern Learning Environment leadership and diverse styles.
‘Leading complex change requires trying on different perspectives to understand the various ways people respond to change.When I first stepped into Lyn Jobson's school in Melbourne, Australia, and
A great basis for working with chidren
saw the open classrooms, I must admit that I flashed back to some bad memories of my own school days in the 1970s, when our "open classrooms" had wide breezeways into shared space instead of doors and were separated by thin, movable walls. What I recall most was the noise, distracting outbursts from other classrooms—and carpenters turning up circa 1980 to reinstall the doors.Yet Jobson's K–8 public school, Alamanda College, was different.’

From Bruce’s ‘goldie oldies’ file:

 Creating Conditions for Creativity. Steven Johnson's 'Where Good Ideas Come From’
‘If organisations such as schools and classrooms embraced creating the conditions for creativity  they would do better at nurturing new ideas. Johnson writes that we are better by connecting ideas than building walls around them – good ideas want to be free, they want to connect, fuse, recombine.’

Survival of the fittest or the best connected - Market Forces or creating conditions for all to thrive. A new look at Darwin.
Charles Darwin
From the same author as above – where good ideas come from.
‘Steven Johnson, in his book 'Where Good Ideas Come From',writes that Darwin realised that the true story of nature was not just one of ruthless competition. Darwin understood well the paradox of the  importance of interdependence as well as competition.Johnson writes that the most creative ideas come from open environments where people share and build on each others ideas - in Darwin's day the coffee shop. Creating such fertile ideas environments is the theme of Johnson's book.’

The miracle of community
The power of an organic learning community.
‘For the past decade or so schools have been too busy, sidetracked trying to implement imposed technocratic curriculums and accountability demands, to consider a more effective way of working, that of being a ‘learning community’. And, in turn, teachers have become so obsessed with complying with requirements that they too have neglected the real source of power – shared beliefs that they and their students forge through working together for their mutual benefit.’